10 Most-read Blog Posts of 2020 About “Internal Auditors” From Mr. Richard Chambers
10 Signs Trouble May Be Brewing for the CAE and Internal Audit
By Richard Chambers, President and Chief Executive Officer of The Institute of Internal Auditors
Top 10 signs that stakeholders may be unhappy with internal audit in my very first blog, in 2009. I continued to share my view on stakeholder perspectives, most recently in my latest book, The Speed of Risk: Lessons Learned on the Audit Trail, 2nd Edition, published in 2019.
I believe that waning support for internal audit is an inherent risk we face as internal audit leaders. For that reason, here is an updated list of “10 Signs Trouble May Be Brewing for the CAE and Internal Audit.”
- You are executing an annual audit plan developed from a risk assessment conducted six months earlier, you have no mechanism for identifying new or emerging risks, and no new audits have been added in the past two months.
- Management and the audit committee are surfacing more new risks to you than you are to them.
- Audit committee members are citing with increasing frequency “best internal audit practices” they observe in other companies on whose boards they serve.
- You are getting a lot of pressure from your stakeholders to undergo an external quality assessment that is past due. Worse yet, they insist that an external quality assessment be undertaken earlier than the five-year interval required by The IIA’s International Professional Practices Framework. A case like this surfaced recently in Dallas.
- Directions that your budget/staffing be reduced are coming from the CEO or chief financial officer, and you are not even being asked about the impact. What’s more, the audit committee is expressing no concerns about internal audit staffing reductions.
- You find yourself on the audit committee agenda with less and less frequency, or you notice that audit committee members use your presentation time to catch up on emails or take a bathroom break.
- Your stakeholders are hiring outside service providers to undertake projects that internal audit is capable of executing.
- You announce your retirement, and the CFO or CEO move quickly to reassign an executive in the company with no internal audit experience as your replacement, overlooking highly qualified internal audit leaders from your department, whom you recommended.
- The CFO or CEO controls the audit committee agenda and tells you what you can or cannot present at meetings. They also insist that any calls you make to the audit committee chair be run by them first for approval and that you must report back on the content of the call.
- The CFO or CEO asks you if the company “really needs an internal audit function.”
I updated my list by asking recent CAEs for further insight and examples. Their input was eye-opening. I am sure there are countless other signs pointing to a loss of stakeholder confidence in, or support of, internal audit. I welcome you to share them.
Copyright 2020 – Richard F Chambers and The Institute of Internal Auditors. Article was orignally published in Feb 2020 at ,The Institute of Internal Auditors website iaonline.theiia.org/blogs.
Mr . Richard Chambers Serve as the Global President and CEO of The Institute of Internal Auditors (IIA), representing 195,000 members in 170 countries worldwide. The IIA is the internal audit profession’s global voice, chief advocate, recognized authority, acknowledged leader, and principal educator. Serve along with the Chairman of the Board, as the chief spokesperson and advocate on behalf of the global internal audit profession.
Direct more than 200 professional staff at the IIA Global Headquarters in achieving the agreed-upon strategies and objectives on behalf of the North American and Global Boards of Directors.
Over almost 10-years as the Global CEO, The IIA has achieved unparalleled growth and progress, including record membership, more than 100% increase in gross revenues, and a 800% increase in net assets. As CEO, directed the launch of the Audit Executive Center, the Certification in Risk Management Assurance, Internal Auditor Online, the AuditChannel.tv, and the American Center for Government Auditing. Serve concurrently on the COSO Board of Directors and the International Integrated Reported Council. Recognized by the Orlando Business Journal as “CEO of the Year” honoree in 2016.
Author of two award-winning books: “Lessons Learned on the Audit Trail” in 2013 and “Trusted Advisors: Key Attributes of Outstanding Internal Auditors” in 2017.
- Fraud Report Affirms Internal Audit’s Value at Critical Time - January 14, 2021
- IFRS 13 Fair Value Measurement - January 11, 2021
- Internal Audit, COVID-19 Risks, and the Year Ahead - January 3, 2021